Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Teak patio chairs beside a brick home overlook a spacious dormant lawn and autumn trees in a Broken Arrow neighborhood.
In the Know

What Changes When Your Broken Arrow House Sits East of 23rd Street

November 19, 2026

Broken Arrow is one city with one mayor and one city council, but it sits in two counties. The City's own street map labels 23rd Street "County Line Road/193rd East Avenue." Tulsa County is to the west. Wagoner County is to the east, where the section-line roads continue as 37th Street/209th East Avenue, Evans/225th, Oneta/241st and Midway/257th. Two houses can share a Broken Arrow address and city services and still differ in their tax levy, their water provider and the county market they sell into.

It pays to know which side a house is on before you choose a street. As of this fall, the Wagoner side of Broken Arrow has a lower total levy, a different water provider across most of it, and a county market where prices are rising while sales fall and inventory builds. That combination gives an east-side buyer more room to negotiate than the headline price suggests.

The line, the levy and the water

Start with the tax rate, since it's the one number on the closing paperwork that follows you for as long as you own the house.

Broken Arrow address County Total levy Period printed on the source
Broken Arrow city, Broken Arrow School District Tulsa 128.08 mills "2026"
Broken Arrow city, Union School District Tulsa 132.46 mills "2026"
Broken Arrow city, Bixby School District Tulsa 135.06 mills "2026"
Broken Arrow city Wagoner 115.86 mills Taxable 2025, fiscal 2025-2026

The Tulsa County figures come from the Tulsa County Assessor's school district rate table, which is headed "School District Tax Rates — 2026." The school district names there are taxing-district labels and nothing more. The Wagoner County figure comes from the Wagoner County levy sheet, which lists Broken Arrow at 115.86 mills for taxable year 2025, fiscal year 2025-2026. The two tables were published for different periods, so I won't put an exact dollar figure on the gap. Still, the Wagoner number sits about a dozen mills below the lowest Broken Arrow rate in Tulsa County. On a house you plan to keep for ten years, that's a line item worth comparing before you write an offer. This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Check the levy that applies to a specific parcel with the county treasurer or a tax professional.

Water is the second difference, and fewer buyers ask about it. The city's comprehensive plan says the Tulsa County portion of Broken Arrow gets City of Broken Arrow water. Most of the Wagoner County portion is served by Rural Water District No. 4, and the plan names the Forest Ridge golf community as one place where the district sold water rights inside city limits. On the east side, the utility account you set up at closing may not be the city's, and the provider is worth checking during your inspection period, the same way I'd check a well and septic on a rural tract.

The plan also describes development in the Wagoner County part of Broken Arrow as more rural, with agricultural and vacant land especially common in the unincorporated eastern fenceline. It expects most new residential growth to stay in Tulsa County, where most existing homes already are. That plan dates to around 2019. The east side's projects since then show where the city has been putting its own money.

The city's biggest recent bet is on the Wagoner side

Events Park is at 21101 E. 101st Street, east of NSU and the Creek Turnpike. The 21101 address number puts it east of 193rd East Avenue, the road the City labels County Line Road. It has a fishing pond, shelters, a playground and the Challenger Sports Complex. The City reports that its 2026 improvements included internal and external roadwork, parking, a pedestrian bridge, paths and lighting. They also included a new on-ramp from the park to the northbound Creek Turnpike, which the Oklahoma Turnpike Authority approved on August 6, 2024. We covered how that roadwork came together in our post on Events Park's new roads and Scotfest's final run.

The roads were built for the amphitheater just north of the park. It was announced as the Sunset Amphitheater and renamed Regent Bank Amphitheater in June 2026. KRMG reported that the first event is scheduled for December 4, a Winter Preview with A Magical Cirque Christmas in a nearly 5,000-seat theater configuration. The full 12,500-seat capacity is planned for an inaugural summer 2027 season. If you're looking at homes near 101st and the turnpike, the event traffic pattern starts on December 4 and grows next summer. Drive it on a show night before you commit.

The private projects around it are smaller and more practical. In February 2024, the City reported rezoning and a PUD approved for Antler Falls, a residential project at the southeast corner of Houston Street and Midway Road. In the same round, it approved rezoning for a commercial development at Kenosha and Oneta, and a separate rezoning at Kenosha and Evans in preparation for a QuikTrip. In December 2025, the Planning Commission took up American Storage of BA, a proposed 24.9-acre PUD west of the Creek Turnpike, east of 209th East Avenue and north of Houston Street.

Housing on the far east edge is still in the early stages. The Broken Arrow Sentinel reported on a 75-acre tract north of Washington Street and west of Oneta Road that was presented for voluntary annexation this fall. The City expects a future single-family subdivision there. A single-family residence sits on the tract now, it would be zoned agricultural after annexation, and future infrastructure costs fall to the owner or developer. The same report described the county's stretch of Oneta south of the turnpike bridge as in poor condition. That's a practical note for anyone who would use Oneta every day. Farther out, the Sentinel noted that Angus Acres was developed in unincorporated Wagoner County, outside city limits. East of 23rd Street, "Broken Arrow" can mean a platted subdivision, rural acreage inside the fenceline or a county address with a Broken Arrow mailing label. Each of those is a different purchase.

The county numbers point both ways

The figures below are countywide reports compiled from Greater Tulsa Association of REALTORS data by MLS Technology. They cover all of Wagoner County and all of Tulsa County, not Broken Arrow alone, so read them as the market each side of the line sells into.

In September 2026, the Wagoner County report shows a median sale price of $295,000. That's up 9.18% from $270,188 in September 2025. Over the same comparison, closed sales fell from 158 to 121 and pending sales dropped 29.58%. Month-end inventory rose 15.35% to 526 homes, or 3.95 months of supply.

When the median rises 9% while closings fall by nearly a quarter, it can reflect which homes sold that month as much as what any one house is worth. A median is the middle of whatever closed. If fewer modest homes close and more newer, larger ones do, the middle moves up even when the typical house hasn't gained 9%. The supply side tells you more about leverage. More homes are sitting, and fewer buyers are going under contract. Homes that did sell went quickly, at a median of 20 days on market, down from 30 a year earlier, and at a median 100% of list price. Put together, well-priced homes are still selling fast, and the growing pile of inventory is the homes priced above what buyers would pay.

Tulsa County shows a steadier picture on the same September 2026 window. The Tulsa County report shows 722 closings, down 1.37% from a year earlier, and 2,540 homes in inventory, or 3.42 months of supply. Average days on market to sale was 42.66, and the average sale price was $343,120, at 98.02% of list. Wagoner County's average sale price for September 2026 was $348,473, so typical prices on the two sides of the line are close. The difference is momentum. Tulsa County's sales held roughly level from last September. Wagoner County's fell, and its supply grew faster.

For a buyer comparing a house near Kenosha and Evans with a similar one west of 23rd Street, that adds up to a clear case. The east-side house sits under a lower levy and in a county market with more homes to choose from and fewer competing buyers. The amphitheater, the turnpike ramp and the Events Park upgrades are bringing more activity to that side of town. A buyer who checks the levy, the water provider and how long comparable homes have been listed has more to negotiate with than price alone.

If you already own on the Tulsa County side and are thinking about a move east, or out to acreage, the timing of the two sales matters more than either price. I walked through that sequence in selling in Broken Arrow while buying land. You can start with a home valuation to see where your current house stands.

Common questions

Which county is Broken Arrow in? Both. 23rd Street, which the City labels County Line Road/193rd East Avenue, is the dividing road. Most addresses west of it are in Tulsa County and most east of it are in Wagoner County.

Does a Broken Arrow address mean city water? Not always. The comprehensive plan says most of the Wagoner County side is served by Rural Water District No. 4. Ask the seller for a recent water bill, which shows the provider.

When does the new amphitheater start hosting shows? Regent Bank Amphitheater's first scheduled event is the December 4 Winter Preview. The full-capacity outdoor season is planned for summer 2027.

If you're weighing a house on one side of 23rd Street against one on the other, I'll pull the levy, the water provider and how long comparable homes nearby have sat for both, so you can see the real difference before you make an offer. Schedule your free consultation with Jeremy Grumbles and bring the two addresses.

Follow Me On Instagram